K-On! Blu-ray Box review!

In 2008, TBS producer Yoshihisa Nakayama took on a risk when deciding to make a TV anime series adaptation of a manga right after the first volume was published! In the end, his risk paid off immensely for TBS as K-On! became one of the big hit shows of 2009 (really only behind Bakemonogatari in popularity). The series was the first Kyoto Animation production to be released on Blu-ray (back in 2009), so it took 5 years (and a necessity of additional revenue to shore up the fiscal year) for TBS to greenlight a BD-Box in March 2014. This is a review of that box set.

SAM_3230

SAM_3234editTBS paid for 14 episodes of K-On! to be made, planning to broadcast at least the first 12 of them and maybe having a “bonus” episode air with another episode to encourage people to buy at least the 7th BD/DVD volume (conveniently packaged with a storage box for all 7, encouraging people to buy the other 6 to fill it up!). This box was planned similarly. TBS decided for 5 discs to have each of the main 5 girls on their own disc and not to leave anyone out. That necessitated the main 12 episodes to be split into 4 episode portions on discs 1-3 and the bonus episodes + bonus features on the 4th disc. (the 5th would be a CD). And so that’s how this 5 disc set was designed.

SAM_3232 SAM_3236 SAM_3231

TBS also made a decision to have it be an “album” type package with a cut-open front cover and various images to be highlighted. There’s the center of the newly drawn digipak (showing the opposite side from volume 7’s cover art), the back of the box (also newly drawn), and postcards featuring the key visuals and cover art from the singles. The digipak itself has a nice continuous image that fits the mood of the first season.

yamadaxyoshida07

Pony Canyon used the same video masters from the singles, just encoded onto a new disc with new menus (that are still images with BGM played over). Additionally, the same audio masters are used, including the main feature audio, audio commentary from the cast, and audio commentary from the staff for each episode. Newly recorded commentary was performed for the episodes on disc 3 with Yamada and the main cast members. The “Ura-On!” shorts, textless OPs/ED, commercials and Toyosaki Aki interview are all on disc 4. All episodes and bonus content (except OP/ED/CMs) have both Japanese and English subtitles.

yamadaxyoshida03

Since this was at the beginning of BD encoding/mastering, Pony’s masters have some banding issues at times. It’s not the worst video I’ve ever seen, nor is it as good as later releases. It’s serviceable for this show while continuing to highlight the impressive visual cuts. Similarly, the audio is a good stereo mix and the commentaries range from okay (mostly cast) to enjoyable (staff).

Also included (and another possible album cover) is a book containing the information from the cards included in the singles as well as design materials such as Yui’s room and her path to school, anniversary messages from the cast/staff, and a summary of the credits shown for each episode (minus each episode’s animators, painters, & photographers).  Finally, included in the package is a flip calendar that can be used for many years to come.

SAM_3239 SAM_3240 SAM_3241
SAM_3242 SAM_3243 SAM_3244

Overall, it’s a great set if you’re interested in K-On! and/or want the “Ura-On!” shorts with subtitles. As usual, TBS doesn’t include any English dubs, so those looking for one will have to go domestic. I’d argue this one is almost better than the original (if you don’t want doll cutouts, sheet music, or picks). I’m certainly glad it’s in my collection.

8 thoughts on “K-On! Blu-ray Box review!

  1. I’d be all over this except for the key thing you leave out – it’s $230 plus shipping! At that price, I can live with my DVDs (and especially considering that the second season is far superior).

  2. “All episodes and bonus content (except OP/ED/CMs) have both Japanese and English subtitles.”

    Wait, was this a small error in writing up, or are there actually English subs for the commentary tracks too? Since I did import both boxes a few months ago, but in checking I couldn’t find any way to turn on subs for anything beyond the basic audio track.

    Granted I wasn’t really expecting English subs for the commentary tracks to begin with (both due to largely being a Japanese market primarily focused release as well as the extra time/effort it’d take to transcribe, so translating was possible, for something that would really only be used by a niche of a niche of a niche), but if I was missing something, then I’d certainly love to know what to do to access it.

  3. “Pony’s masters have some banding issues at times. It’s not the worst video I’ve ever seen, nor is it as good as later releases.”

    Thanks for the review.

    When you say later releases, do you mean the 2015 BD release? Was the banding fixed by then?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s