Megax’s Favorite Character #10: A Melancholic, Sighful, Boring, Disappearing, Rampaging, Wavering, Intriguing, Angry, Dissociating, and Surprising Young Woman

And so the final character to round out my top ten favorite characters should come as no surprise (after four years of course). As the titular character in the franchise that is synonymous with the phrase Light Novel in Japan, this character appealed to many all around the world. She’s been in many countries, even as a sign of peace during wartime, and is known to most anime fans. The final member of my top ten is the one who Saved the World by Overloading it with Fun: Haruhi Suzumiya! That is all!

Out of all the brigade members, I feel that Haruhi is the most detailed (mostly from the first novel). I feel that Haruhi is emotionally, and very likely socially still a child. Her actions are rash and without consideration of others, until her growth in November from Sigh and the ensuing recovery in Live a Live. She wanted so much to believe that there was something special about the people around her in elementary school and when she realized how small of a world it is, it broke her heart tremendously.

Haruhi symbolizes the child inside all of us who never grew up. She’s the one who desires to believe in the impossible and yet somehow was able to acquire the power to make that happen. It’s the ultimate irony: she has the ability to make all of her wishes come true (and subconsciously they do), but she won’t find out about it. I wonder if that’s how her power will go away: she finally realizes that the world is fine the way it is with no super humans or time travelers.

Does Haruhi mean to hurt her friends? I’d argue heavily against it. Ignoring future stories, she’s been shown to always want to help someone in need although not always in the optimum method. Even in Sigh, she’s just trying to get Mikuru to be a better actress. The novel states it better where she’s trying to get Mikuru to have a reaction rather than just hitting her. She offers to share an umbrella with Kyon; she stays after to help edit the movie, she takes over for a sick member in a band, and she stayed by Kyon’s side all three days he was unconcious. Her loneliness from middle school has gone away and she truly treasures the people around her.

Haruhi reminds me of that person. When something needs to happen for her, it happens. Of course she has supernatural powers to help her, but things always seem to go her way when she least expects it. She’s able to do well on tests because she knows what to study and thus that’s what ends up being on the exam. She can’t comprehend how people can study and do poorly like Kyon. She tries to fit everything into things she’s seen rather than what they could be like in Mysterique Sign where the Computer Club President went missing.  That’s why Kyon is a good match for her. He’s a grounding force that she needs to move forward.

She cares deeply for Kyon, yet she’s afraid to realize it. The last big things in her life (her special viewpoint and John Smith) were lost to her and I think she’s somewhat afraid he’ll leave her behind too. With how she stayed by his side and was depressed in Sigh are just two examples, but Someday in the Rain, Lone Island Syndrome, and Boredom all show how important he is to her. I can’t wait to see how their relationship develops.

Besides being the force driving me into anime, Haruhi is special to me because she reminds me of myself. I do dream about the supernatural types of beings she imagines regardless of what science has taught me because it’s more fun to imagine the impossible. Her ability to luck into things is something I’ve noticed that often happens to me as well. I think her quote about love in Melancholy fits what I feel about love as well (with the caveat that I think “whatever happens will happen”). She wants the best for everyone around her and will do anything for them, much like I think I do for my friends. She’s the side of me who’s afraid to grow up in the real world.

After Nagisa and Saten, Haruhi is the third most well developed character I’ve seen. She’s not a tsundere, she’s not genki, she’s just Haruhi due to the depth in her. Melancholy is one of the finest stories I’ve read/seen and her change from the prologue to the end is a great transition in writing. She visibly grows throughout the series bit-by-bit until (censored for novel spoilers). There are flaws in her character, but they’re realistic for her and ones that are entertaining to see overcome.

I have to comment that the Disappearance!Haruhi is one of the most appealing character designs in anime to me and is one of the reasons Haruhi is my favorite. Seeing the long hair make its return (without the ponytail) was a great addition to her design and emphasized the change that Kyon makes in her life. The contrast of her hairbands is further aided with the Kyounen uniform to draw even more attention, not to mention the uniform itself has amazing style by itself. The anime version emphasized that design even better than I imagined in the novel and I’m always sad to see it go away in the story.

Then what about me? What did “Haruhi Suzumiya” mean to me? Haruhi was Haruhi and nobody else.

That sums it up perfectly. Haruhi is Haruhi and is someone special to me. She’s the one who got me into anime and for that I’m always grateful to her franchise. Her character is one of the best I’ve seen. All that means one thing: there’s no better person to round out my top ten with. I hope you enjoyed it!

Edit: I forgot to include the last version of Haruhi on BD, so here you go!

10 thoughts on “Megax’s Favorite Character #10: A Melancholic, Sighful, Boring, Disappearing, Rampaging, Wavering, Intriguing, Angry, Dissociating, and Surprising Young Woman

  1. > After Nagisa and Saten, Haruhi is the third most well developed character I’ve seen

    I wonder who you’re ranking them against. It’ll be interesting to find out.

    • If you eliminate those “hideously unproportional” and “impossibly well-endowed” from the competition and focus on the “normal”, I see what you mean…

      • It’s a genuine interest of mine to know what people find to be good character development. It doesn’t have to be “realistic” though.

        Your mention of Saten piqued my curiosity, because her character arc was the thing I want to remember about Railgun… but I’d have a very difficult time ranking characters by their development.

        • If there is one thing that the Railgun anime did, it was enhance Saten from a minor plot device in the manga to a phenomenal character. If asked, there’d be about five people that I say would be the best developed (writing-wise) characters in anime: Nagisa, Saten, Haruhi, Taiga, and then Tomoya. Those five stand above all others just by how deeply involved they are without any inconsistencies. I’ve not seen a lot of older shows, so there’s likely others that I’d move into when I’ve seen them, but those are the ones I’d say to be the best developed ones of shows I’ve seen.

      • Well, when I refer to “well developed” characters, I mean writing-wise. Are character models important in a character? Yes, but breast size is not something that is important to me.

    • Well, all 10 of my favorite characters have been revealed. The links are in the About This Blog link on the top of the page. But I’m referring to all anime characters in general when I say those three are the most well-developed. Nagisa has flaws, but overall I feel that she’s the best written character in an anime series. Saten would be number two and now Haruhi would be number three (though I am biased due to future arcs).

      • Yes, I managed to get some time to read through them now. They’re interesting choices, and remind me of my own top ten from about ten years ago, which brought a smile to my face.

        It was neat to see how my list evolved as I watched more anime, so I hope you get that kind of experience as well as you watch more 🙂

        It’s always nice to see someone who cares about characters in terms of how well they’re written. Most people’s standards for “good character development” is simply what you’ll get from average hack writing, so this read was a treat. Thanks!

        • Thank you for the wonderful compliments. It’s always a delight to be praised. I hope you stick around as there’s always more to talk about (if I can ever get it down on screen). The future is always unknown, so I hope my list changes as even more amazing characters are created.

          Plot is one of the most important aspects of a show to me. Visual can be overlooked (as is the case with Moshidora) for an incredible plot that is above the average. As you say, most shows have average writing and thus their characters tend to be weak. I’ll even admit that Saki suffers from average writing, but someone became amazing to me from it even though she’s not a great written character. I see it as simply rewarding those who put the extra effort into great characters versus a great amount of characters (Railgun versus Index comes to mind).

  2. Congrats on completing your top 10 ^_^ After completing mine towards the end of 2009, I find it interesting to go back now and see which ones have and haven’t changed. I hope a year or so from now you’ll find interesting changes in your list too!

    You know how I feel about Haruhi so I can either write you an essay as a comment or just keep it short XD Since I’ve already written quite a bit about her, I’ll keep it short and just say that I agree with all you’ve said =D

    Oh, and in regards to the title, I would have used “bored” instead of “boring.” You certainly don’t think she’s boring, do you? 😉

    • I know more and more will likely change. I can safely say that the top three will remain unchanged while some of the others may drop out (minus Mikuru and Haruhi, they just fit so perfectly in the list). Ohana’s looking to be a strong contender as well as Victorique and Elsie, so we’ll see how things are in a year.

      Oh, there’s so much that’s been said between us on Haruhi that it could take up two more posts and we’d still find more to say. It’s almost difficult not to touch on something either of us has said before, which I accomplished somehow.

      There has been a couple of times where Haruhi has been boring to me so that was somewhat apt, but Tanigawa has been able to bring freshness into the story with some of the newer stories. I think either word would fit though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s